LONDON – Oil executives betting they will be able to meet net-zero emissions goals by relying on carbon-capture technology are deluding themselves, according to an influential group of corporate bosses, bankers and academics.
The Energy Transitions Commission (ETC), whose members include senior representatives from BP and Bank of America, says the role of carbon capture, utilisation and storage (CCUS) in slashing emissions will be “vital but limited.”
Any carbon-intensive company assuming that CCUS is a licence to continue expanding production, while at the same time limiting the increase in global temperatures, is basing its business model on “a dangerous delusion,” the ETC said in a report on Thursday.
The findings come just two weeks before COP28 climate talks get under way in Dubai. The summit will be presided over by the head of the state-backed Abu Dhabi National Oil Company (Adnoc), which has said it can raise production and cut emissions at the same time by investing in carbon capture technology.
“The big debate at COP is going to be whether you get rid of fossil fuel use, or if you keep using fossil fuels at the current level, and you just add CCUS” and direct air capture, according to Mr Adair Turner, the former City of London finance regulator who now chairs the ETC.
Representatives from oil-producing nations may say that “of course we can go on producing a hundred million barrels of oil a day for the next 50 years, and we’ll do enough direct air capture to offset it”, he said. “And on the other hand, you’ll have a lot of non-governmental organisations and renewable energy companies saying this whole CCUS and DAC thing is a bit of a con trick, and it’s a deliberate device by the fossil fuel companies to explain why they can go on producing fossil fuels forever.”
According to the ETC’s calculations, the cost of developing CCUS isn’t declining, and projects aren’t being developed at the expected pace. At the same time, progress made towards getting the necessary financing for such projects has been “very disappointing” over the past 18 months, the ETC said.
Mr Turner says the appropriate mix is 85 per cent real emissions reductions, with CCUS and DAC taking care of the rest.
With fossil fuel production, processing and combustion responsible for 90 per cent of global CO2 emissions and 35 per cent of methane emissions, COP28 talks need to secure an agreement around a phase-down of all fossil fuels, the ETC said.
The ETC estimated last year that roughly 150 gigatonnes of carbon removals “could be delivered” by 2050, by tapping a portfolio of nature-based and technological solutions. Reaching that goal requires that “adequate finance” be mobilised, the commission said on Thursday. BLOOMBERG
