Is #boymom trend a sign of motherly love or something ‘toxic’?

Influencer Avery Woods with her son and younger daughter. PHOTO: AVERYYWOODS/INSTAGRAM

NEW YORK – Avery Woods has deleted a video that made her the subject of recent online discussion, but that does not matter.

The Internet never forgets.

Woods, an influencer and podcast host with more than two million followers on TikTok, posted the video earlier in March, in which she appeared in the eyes of some to prefer one of her children over the other.

It shows her sitting in her car after receiving her son’s recent school pictures. “My boy mums feel me on this,” Woods says in the video, “but my son has my heart. My heart and my soul.”

She adds that she is “obsessed” with her daughter: “She is just the greatest little girl in the whole world. But my whole life, I always wanted to be a boy mum.”

Then she shows off several photos of her son.

A boy mum would seem to be just that: a mother to a male child. Online, however, the term has been taken to represent a mother who takes special enjoyment in raising a son.

There are nearly 18 million posts with the hashtag #boymom on Instagram. On TikTok, the same hashtag accounts for more than 31 billion views.

Some videos use romantic language to describe a mother’s relationships to her children.

“You’ll be his first kiss, his first love, his first friend,” goes a popular audio track that many boy mums have used in videos of their child. “You are his mum, and he is your whole world.”

Woods, who declined to comment for this article through a spokesperson, frequently posts video content that shows her doting on both of her children without causing a firestorm.

The video that centred on her feelings for her son, though, led to a debate that went on for days.

“POV: you’re a boy mum who does not feel her on this,” one TikTok user wrote on screen in a response video.

Abby Eckel, a content creator in Kansas who regularly posts about motherhood, wrote a lengthy caption to her reaction video: “This type of relationship tends to not have or allow boundaries, creating an unhealthy relationship. I would never place that much pressure on my son(s) to tell them one of them is my ‘heart and soul’.”

Eckel, who is 35 and has two sons, said in an interview that boy mums have “a lot of negative connotations”, including the idea that they are “weirdly obsessed” with their sons.

Eckel added that her concerns were not about a single mother or a single video, but about “the toxic messaging that a lot of mums perpetuate”.

Dr Sylvia Mikucki-Enyart, a communication studies professor at the University of Iowa who focuses on family dynamics, said she found Woods’ video to be innocuous.

But she added that she had broader concerns about adults who post content about their children. She said that parents who expressed a strong preference for a child based on gender may create unintended consequences.

“It sets up or reinforces these really gendered expectations we have for these extended family relationships,” said Dr Mikucki-Enyart, who is 42 and has one son.

She called the #boymom trend “toxic”, saying it could lead to family tensions between mothers who call themselves boy mums and their sons’ romantic partners.

“I know some people joke, ‘Oh, you’re taking it too seriously. It’s just a fun little hashtag,’” Dr Mikucki-Enyart said. “But words matter. Messages matter.” NYTIMES

Join ST's WhatsApp Channel and get the latest news and must-reads.